Movies Books Travel Food Other
Trending
New
Popular

Menu Items From Papa's Bakeria to Go!

"Papa's Bakeria To Go!" is a video game in which you are supposed to serve pies to various customers! How many of the game items have you eaten in a pie in real life?
Note A: Some of the fictional items that are in the game have been replaced with real-life variants.
Note B: I apologize for making this list almost completely identical to my list that lists menu items from Papa's Bakeria. The mobile version of this game almost has identical items to the website version, with the exception of its Cherry Blossom items being replaced with Big Top Carnival items. I should have put the items in one list, instead of making two of them for the respective game versions.
Series: Foods from video games.
No: 4.
43 users · 1,040 views
avg. score: 32 of 123 (26%)
required scores: 1, 7, 25, 35, 51 

How many have you tried in a pie?

Page 1 of 4
Chocolate Crust
Chocolate Crust
1
Graham Cracker Crust
Graham Cracker Crust
2
Traditional Crust
Traditional Crust
3
Oreo Crust
Oreo Crust
4
Ladyfinger Crust
Ladyfinger Crust
5
Red Velvet Crust
Red Velvet Crust
6
Vanilla Wafer Crust
Vanilla Wafer Crust
7
Chocolate Chip Crust
Chocolate Chip Crust
8
Peanut Butter Swirl Crust
Peanut Butter Swirl Crust
9
Gingersnap Crust
Gingersnap Crust
10
Pecan Filling
Pecan Filling
11
Cherry Filling
Cherry Filling
12
Apple Filling
Apple Filling
13
Fudge Filling
Fudge Filling
14
Banana Filling
Banana Filling
15
Toffee Filling
Toffee Filling
16
Cheesecake Filling
Cheesecake Filling
17
Strawberry Filling
Strawberry Filling
18
Key Lime Filling
Key Lime Filling
19
Marshmallow Filling
Marshmallow Filling
20
Lemon Filling
Lemon Filling
21
Sugarplum Filling
Sugarplum Filling
22
Dragonfruit Filling
Dragonfruit Filling
23
Pineapple Filling
Pineapple Filling
24
Peach Filling
Peach Filling
25
Blueberry Filling
Blueberry Filling
26
Kiwi Filling
Kiwi Filling
27
Rhubarb Filling
Rhubarb Filling
28
Purple Yam Filling
Purple Yam Filling
29
Peanut Butter Fluff Filling
Peanut Butter Fluff Filling
30
Tutti Frutti Filling
Tutti Frutti Filling
31
Pomegranate Filling
Pomegranate Filling
32
Chocolate Mint Custard Filling
Chocolate Mint Custard Filling
33
Jellybean Jam Filling
Jellybean Jam Filling
34
Circus Peanut Filling
Circus Peanut Filling
35
Passionfruit Filling
Passionfruit Filling
36
Mulberry Medley Filling
Mulberry Medley Filling
37
Starfruit Filling
Starfruit Filling
38
Mission Fig Jam Filling
Mission Fig Jam Filling
39
Blackberry Cloudberry (Shadowberry) Filling
Blackberry Cloudberry (Shadowberry) Filling
40
Page 1 of 4
Click foods you've tried
Newsletter · Help/Contact · Privacy · Copyright Claim   © 2025 App Spring, Inc. · This product uses the TMDb API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDb.
Seen It - Movies & TV 
Android & iOS
Seen It is a new app from the creators of List Challenges. You can view movies and shows in one place and filter by streaming provider, genre, release year, runtime, and rating (Rotten Tomatoes, Imdb, and/or Metacritic). Also, you can track what you've seen, want to see, like, or dislike, as well as track individual seasons or episodes of shows. In addition, you can see the most watched/liked stuff amongst your friends. Learn more at SEENIT.FUN