I took the top 45 List Challenge lists of a Feel Good/Inspiring/Comforting/Heart Warming/Feel Good/Thought Provoking/Make You Think/Mind Blowing nature, all with a User base of at least 2,000, tabulated a total sum of each movie's % of users value taken from each list's Stats tab, and divided that total by the # of lists in which the film appeared. This AVERAGE watched % list was then sorted and ranked.
Yeah, more of a Heart/Mind list which is why I combined the Mind Blowing/Thought Provoking ('Se7en', 'Usual Suspects,' 'Memento', 'Being John Malkovich,' etc) with the Feel Good/Warmth films. And don't forget the "Moving" films which I believe is why 'Requiem for a Dream" appeared on several lists - a movie that would not be on a "Feel Good" list by any stretch.