List Challenges
Movies Books Travel Food Other
Trending
New
Popular
Sign In
 Make a List Browse Lists Search Lists Leaders Help / Contact Newsletter

50 of the Strangest Unsolved Mysteries From Each State

"Every state harbors unpleasant secrets—here are 50 of the strangest ones from around the country, and why we may never learn the real truth."
Credits go to Lauren Cahn and rd.com
147 users · 1,740 views
 
from rd.com
avg. score: 8 of 50 (15%)
required scores: 1, 2, 4, 7, 11 
type to search

How many have you heard about?

Page 1 of 2
Alabama: The Brasher-Dye Disappearance
Alabama: The Brasher-Dye Disappearance
1
Alaska: The Investor Murders
Alaska: The Investor Murders
2
Arizona: Searching for Robert Fisher
Arizona: Searching for Robert Fisher
3
Arkansas: The Gurdon Light
Arkansas: The Gurdon Light
4
California: Did Anyone Survive the "Escape From Alcatraz"?
California: Did Anyone Survive the "Escape From Alcatraz"?
5
Colorado: The Black Forest Haunting
Colorado: The Black Forest Haunting
6
Connecticut: The Shallow Graves Beneath New Haven Green
Connecticut: The Shallow Graves Beneath New Haven Green
7
Delaware: The Inexplicable Murder of Jane Marie Prichard
Delaware: The Inexplicable Murder of Jane Marie Prichard
8
Florida: The Spontaneous Combustion of Mary Reeser
Florida: The Spontaneous Combustion of Mary Reeser
9
Georgia: The Bleeding House
Georgia: The Bleeding House
10
Hawaii: What Happened to Lisa Au?
Hawaii: What Happened to Lisa Au?
11
Idaho: Strange Mutilations
Idaho: Strange Mutilations
12
Illinois: The Mad Gasser of Mattoon
Illinois: The Mad Gasser of Mattoon
13
Indiana: The Mysterious Fire Poltergeist
Indiana: The Mysterious Fire Poltergeist
14
Iowa: The Boy With No Appetite
Iowa: The Boy With No Appetite
15
Kansas: The Baffling Disappearance of Randy Leach
Kansas: The Baffling Disappearance of Randy Leach
16
Kentucky Meat Shower
Kentucky Meat Shower
17
Louisiana: The Unknowable Marie Laveau
Louisiana: The Unknowable Marie Laveau
18
Maine: What Happened to Sarah Ware?
Maine: What Happened to Sarah Ware?
19
Maryland: House of Horrors
Maryland: House of Horrors
20
Massachusetts: The Black Flash of Provincetown
Massachusetts: The Black Flash of Provincetown
21
Michigan: What Exactly Is the Paulding Light?
Michigan: What Exactly Is the Paulding Light?
22
Minnesota: The Frozen Girl, Defrosted
Minnesota: The Frozen Girl, Defrosted
23
Mississippi: Phantom Barber of Pascagoula
Mississippi: Phantom Barber of Pascagoula
24
Missouri: How Robert Rayford Contracted AIDS
Missouri: How Robert Rayford Contracted AIDS
25
Montana: The Vortex and House of Mystery
Montana: The Vortex and House of Mystery
26
Nebraska: The Lucky 15
Nebraska: The Lucky 15
27
Nevada: Who Murdered Tupac Shakur?
Nevada: Who Murdered Tupac Shakur?
28
New Hampshire: The Disappearance of Rachel Garden
New Hampshire: The Disappearance of Rachel Garden
29
New Jersey: The Phantom Sniper
New Jersey: The Phantom Sniper
30
New Mexico: What Was Really Going on in Roswell?
New Mexico: What Was Really Going on in Roswell?
31
New York: Who Was the Leatherman?
New York: Who Was the Leatherman?
32
North Carolina: The Shadow of the Bear
North Carolina: The Shadow of the Bear
33
North Dakota: Eugene Butler's Crawl Space
North Dakota: Eugene Butler's Crawl Space
34
Ohio: The Circleville Letters
Ohio: The Circleville Letters
35
Oklahoma: The Jamison Family
Oklahoma: The Jamison Family
36
Oregon: The Mysterious Shrieks of Forest Grove
Oregon: The Mysterious Shrieks of Forest Grove
37
Pennsylvania: Boy in the Box
Pennsylvania: Boy in the Box
38
Rhode Island: Where Is Adam Emery?
Rhode Island: Where Is Adam Emery?
39
South Carolina: The Lizard Man
South Carolina: The Lizard Man
40
Page 1 of 2
Click things you've done
Lists Similar to '50 of the Strangest Unsolved Mysteries From Each State'
Unsolved Mysteries From History
Unsolved Mysteries From History
328
30
Unsolved Mysteries
Unsolved Mysteries
172
58
Top 10 Movies Based on Real Unsolved Mysteries
Top 10 Movies Based on Real Unsolved Mysteries
135
10
Books About Florida: The Strangest State in the Union
Books About Florida: The Strangest State in the Union
137
52
State by State: Movies With a State Name in the Title
State by State: Movies With a State Name in the Title
368
164
State by State and Country by Country
State by State and Country by Country
292
392
The Best State Park in Every U.S. State
The Best State Park in Every U.S. State
131
50
The Best State Park in Each State According to the Discoverer Blog
The Best State Park in Each State According to the Discoverer Blog
116
50
10 Mystery Movies That End With the Mystery Left Unsolved
10 Mystery Movies That End With the Mystery Left Unsolved
162
10
Unsolved Cold Cases You Want to Be Answered
Unsolved Cold Cases You Want to Be Answered
82
12
Strangest Movies
Strangest Movies
5,419
228
Top 100 of the Strangest Movies Ever
Top 100 of the Strangest Movies Ever
1,822
100
The Strangest Books Ever Written
The Strangest Books Ever Written
1,755
435
Strangest Foods I've Eaten
Strangest Foods I've Eaten
1,313
24
24 Movies That Viewers Claim Are the Strangest Ever Made (BuzzFeed)
24 Movies That Viewers Claim Are the Strangest Ever Made (BuzzFeed)
463
24
25 of the Strangest Movies We've Ever Watched According to Wealth of Geeks
25 of the Strangest Movies We've Ever Watched According to Wealth of Geeks
401
25
Some of the Strangest Movies I've Seen
Some of the Strangest Movies I've Seen
356
34
Reel Rundown's 15 of the Strangest Movies Ever Made
Reel Rundown's 15 of the Strangest Movies Ever Made
333
15
Strangest Kids Shows
Strangest Kids Shows
283
14
The 10 Strangest Movies of All Time
The 10 Strangest Movies of All Time
234
10
Strangest Movies Chartreuse Has Seen
Strangest Movies Chartreuse Has Seen
193
25
The 13 Strangest Movies We've Ever Seen According to Moviemaker
The 13 Strangest Movies We've Ever Seen According to Moviemaker
186
13
Movies With the Strangest Titles
Movies With the Strangest Titles
179
74
The Strangest Books Carl Palmer Has Yet Read
The Strangest Books Carl Palmer Has Yet Read
149
11
The 10 Strangest Horror Movies of the 1970s, According to Reddit
The 10 Strangest Horror Movies of the 1970s, According to Reddit
149
10
The Strangest Horror Movies of the 1990s, According to Reddit
The Strangest Horror Movies of the 1990s, According to Reddit
134
10
10 Best Sitcoms With the Strangest Titles (CBR.com)
10 Best Sitcoms With the Strangest Titles (CBR.com)
136
10
America's Strangest Museums
America's Strangest Museums
126
105
The 10 Strangest Horror Movies of the 1980s, According to Reddit
The 10 Strangest Horror Movies of the 1980s, According to Reddit
122
10
List25's Strangest Phobias You Could Have
List25's Strangest Phobias You Could Have
117
25
All Similar Lists
Newsletter · Help/Contact · Privacy · Copyright Claim   © 2025 App Spring, Inc. · This product uses the TMDb API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDb.
Seen It - Movies & TV 
Android & iOS
Seen It is a new app from the creators of List Challenges. You can view movies and shows in one place and filter by streaming provider, genre, release year, runtime, and rating (Rotten Tomatoes, Imdb, and/or Metacritic). Also, you can track what you've seen, want to see, like, or dislike, as well as track individual seasons or episodes of shows. In addition, you can see the most watched/liked stuff amongst your friends. Learn more at SEENIT.FUN